Saturday, July 18, 2009

Unit #4 ... Embarking On A Big Project!

At first I had a hard time deciding what to do for this project. So I got to thinking about what handouts I give my students and if any could be needing some changes. Oh boy .... I found that most of the things I hand out would earn an "F-------" in this class and are not very good at presenting the information. So I picked one handout and started an amazing journey through the revision process and conversion to Illustrator. I am really starting to like this program. At first I was soooooooo lost .... but I am getting the hang of it. Here was an original handout I would give out in my Algebra II class. I am sort of embarrassed to show it ... but here it is:


As you can see this is very confusing and not user friendly really at all. In my revision process I applied the concepts we have been learning about. I did my best to use an effective ground in the revision. I especially like the ground in the table that I created. I feel it is very effective. I also used just a little color to show students the steps of graphing. The red in the graphs indicate the current step. Once you move to the next step the red parts turn to black. I feel that this is a good use of color to help emphasize the steps. Here is the image:

Overall I am pleased with this revision. However in testing this image I would appreciate it if you could answer the following questions. #1) Is there too much going on here to make this to complicated .. if so ... any ideas on how to fix it? #2) Is the ground in this image helping students understand/organize concepts. #3) Would it be best to get rid of the circles around the numbers ... not sure if they have a purpose. #4) Are the graphs understandable and is the color helping students identify the current step of the process? #5) Would it be effective to use additional ground techniques for each step of the process .... like I did in the table? #6) Is it clear that f(x) is the function in the numerator and g(x) is the function in the denominator ... or could it be better if I used t(x) for top function and b(x) for bottom function? #7) Are the steps clear?

Well I can't wait to hear about how this went. Thanks for your feedback ... Stephan!

1 comment:

  1. Hey Stephan,
    First of all great job on last week's assignment. I see I got a few right and I really think you made good improvements on the ones you changed.
    Rational functions is a complex topic for many students but I think you've got a good note sheet for them here. I'll go through my thoughts and then address your specific questions.

    The title somewhat washes out in the large black background. There's good contrast, but my eyes are drawn to the rest instead. Perhaps stay in black on white but increase the font size.
    In your original version, I liked that you listed a step (find the zeros) and then both with an arrow and a 'squiggly oval' you then showed what to do. This organization seemed easier than the sentence versions you changed to.
    I like that the steps are clearly numbered. I might put the numbers on the far left, as that is what they read first so that the graph/text are not separated (proximity?)
    From a diamond design standpoint, I would consider leaving out the table for step #4 - I think that dividing the leading terms (and then considering x being really big or small) will show the asymptotes every time. Showing the specific cases might be too busy for this.
    Take those comments or leave them. I might be getting too picky, since I think it's a really good handout for what you're looking to accomplish.

    Now for your questions...
    #1 - kinda covered above.
    #2 - I think you've done well, students will clearly see the steps and be able to follow this.
    #3 - I like the circles, could even use color!
    #4 - The graphs are good, although since you never show the example equation or work, perhaps you could just show single steps rather than the building process in the graphs. (just use the red marks)
    #5 - No I think extra ground techniques would be distracting.
    #6 - You're fine with f(x) and g(x).
    #7 - I understand the steps well. I think your students will give better feedback on that question. We always make clear handouts, right? :-)

    Good Luck!

    ReplyDelete